Are Your Loans Part of the Homaidan Lawsuit and What Does This Mean?
Say you have a private student loan and you have previously filed a bankruptcy. Was your private student loan discharged? I’m presuming you did not file an adversary case to obtain a specific ruling as to dischargeability of these loans.
- What is Homaidan?
Loans that could have been discharged as beyond the cost of attendance, that portion that was over and above tuition, books, room and board etc. may be the subject of Homaidan. My understanding is that you can remain a class member for a discharge of any amounts that are outside of the cost of attendance and you’d remain responsible for anything else. You can also opt out and pursue relief on your own of that or the remainder of the loans, or seek alternative grounds for relief such as ineligible institution, non-dependent borrower or undue hardship.
What is the IDR Recount and What Happens During a Strategy Session with Us?

Prior TPD Discharges are Now Transferring to IDR Recount for Quicker Forgiveness
For people granted TPD, who are also eligible for IDR AUDIT Forgiveness, Dept. is moving TPD people from TPD forgiveness to IDR Audit forgiveness. While there is no 3 year income monitoring on TPD anymore, there still is a three year monitoring on TPD for things such as returning to school so moving them to IDR Audit forgiveness will give these people faster forgiveness.
Forgiveness before 12/31/25 is very good! That’s when the stimulus bill expires allowing for federal tax waiver on any student loan forgiveness (private or federal). It’s also when the TPD discharge provision providing for tax free forgiveness has to be re-funded by Congress. So forgiveness now is Great News! Even if the IDR Waiver is somehow stopped due to someone filing a court case down the road, it is unlikely to unravel a forgiven loan. Rather it would most likely stop anyone in the future from obtaining forgiveness. Of course, someone who has already consolidated their loans for the IDR recount can argue that they relied upon the program’s rules when doing the consolidation, and that laches (a fancy legal term for delay) prevents the creditor from asserting that now.
|
|||||||||
|
|||||||||
|
Why You Need an Adversary in Bankruptcy to Discharge Student Loans
The Supreme Court decision of United Student Aid Funds v. Espinosa (2010) 559 U.S. 260 is usually cited for the proposition that a court may not make an order on whether student debt is discharged without an adversary proceeding.
In USAF v. Espinosa, the issue was whether confirmation of a chapter 13 plan which provided for discharge of the student loan debt could be reversed. Rafael “Ted” Cruz lost in his quest to convince the Supreme Court to void the plan by means of FRCP Rule 60(b)(4).
But bankruptcy judges and practitioners were cautioned to always use an adversary proceeding for determinations on whether educational debt is discharged by § 523(a)(8).
High Interest, High Payment Vehicle Loans – How to Get Out of?
I just put a client together with a reporter doing a story about high interest vehicle loans. I’ll leave the details to him and post here when the story comes out — but I did want to remind folks that there are ways out of these loans.
This particular loan was for 17.45% interest loan. The client made low six figures in income from a very reputable employer at the time. Why such high interest? I’m not sure what her credit score was at the time, but the incredibly high interest rate caused her to pay $58k for a used vehicle she bought at $35k. She made payments for approximately two years, but with a mortgage, and everyday expenses going up, she couldn’t keep it up.
Her solution was to file bankruptcy and surrender the car. This way they couldn’t come after her for the deficiency balance. Other things were addressed in the bankruptcy as well. But this vehicle and the 17.45% interest rate was a leading cause. We assist clients in obtaining other more sustainable vehicles during the bankruptcy – usually with a reasonable interest rate, warranty, sustainable payment. We get that you need a vehicle. You just need one that makes financial sense.
IDR Recount — Yes it’s Real! Here’s a sample:
Dear X,
Congratulations! The Biden-Harris Administration has forgiven your federal student loan(s) listed below with Nelnet in full.This debt relief was processed as part of the Biden-Harris Administration’s one-time account adjustment because your student loan(s) have been in repayment of at least 20 or 25 years. An adjustment to your account updated the number of payments that qualify towards income-driven repayment (IDR) forgiveness. This forgiveness is effective as of 05/15/2020.
Log in to your account for details. WHAT YOU NEED TO KNOWHere are some important points on this IDR forgiveness:
|
How to Count Your Time Toward Student Loan Forgiveness under the IDR Recount
SAVE limitations?
For those of you facing repayment of federal student loans: some people are asking whether SAVE is restricted to certain years of loans like PAYE. Nope.
SAVE is open to all Direct Loan holders, except Parent PLUS. No disbursement restrictions like PAYE. So, as long as you have Direct Loans, without any Parent PLUS loans consolidated into them, they are eligible. If the Parent Plus code is not picked up by your servicer through a double consolidation, it’s possible that SAVE may apply. But with the new Parent Plus Consolidation Indicator added to the National Student Loan Database we believe that loophole may be closing or has already closed. We have no idea if this Indicator will apply to only new consolidations or if the Department or its servicers will go back and change someone’s SAVE, PAYE, REPAYE or IBR to ICR as Congress intended.
Consolidating Loans — Getting a Huge Payment Increase?
Lots of federal student loan borrowers are in the same boat now. Have you consolidated your loans in an effort to get onto SAVE for the lowest possible payment? But it seems to have backfired because your payment is now enormous?
Here’s some tips that you may want to be aware of:
- A new consolidation will always provide an initial payment based upon the 10 year standard. A client today reported her payment was to be $2,000! She knew not to be concerned however because the SAVE review hadn’t yet occurred. It’s a two step process: first, consolidation, then evaluation for SAVE.